Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
-
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2018 1:48 pm
- Location: Fair Green, Norfolk
- Contact:
Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
I stumbled across some forums on battery trains & wonder if anyone has tried the conversion. This was initially brought out for G-rail. But I went the DCC route with on30 scale & so wished i had found this first. It all runs on dry track, so no voltage problems, can use cheap trains, run 12 trains at the same time on one controller. Its very similar to DCC, but works via very similar to RC planes. But there are a few restrictions. You can still have sound, lights, reversing lights & more. The train just needs a battery & receiver. This will normally give about 1-2 hours running before a recharge or battery swap is needed depending on battery size. So here is a list of pros, pop some cons up for me.
PROS:
Controller for 12 trains with facility for switch whistles, lights, horns, sound for each train individually.£75
No points/frog problems
No turnaround loop problems.
No transformers for track
No having to run cables to each length of the rail
The track could be 150met away from where you stand
Doesn't matter if the track gets a short out.
Points on a simple on/off/on toggle switch
Leadless controller
Cons:
Can't stop a train automatically crashing into each other so easy
Recharge needed
Better with trains that have coal tenders to carry batteries & possibly get up to 3-4 hours running per charge.
Any other pros & cons??
Train controller 2.4ghz image below
PROS:
Controller for 12 trains with facility for switch whistles, lights, horns, sound for each train individually.£75
No points/frog problems
No turnaround loop problems.
No transformers for track
No having to run cables to each length of the rail
The track could be 150met away from where you stand
Doesn't matter if the track gets a short out.
Points on a simple on/off/on toggle switch
Leadless controller
Cons:
Can't stop a train automatically crashing into each other so easy
Recharge needed
Better with trains that have coal tenders to carry batteries & possibly get up to 3-4 hours running per charge.
Any other pros & cons??
Train controller 2.4ghz image below
-
- Posts: 388
- Joined: Fri Oct 05, 2018 6:49 pm
- Contact:
Re: Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
I saw a OO version of a battery driven train at a show sometime back and was amazed at the size of the batteries. The thing that struck me was the battery swapping and recharging which involved considerable handling of locos. I was going to ask the exhibitor for more details but he seemed tied up with other punters. It did occur to me afterwards it would handy to recharge the batteries in situ. I was thinking of a powered siding where the loco could be parked up and recharged.
Richard
Richard
-
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2018 1:48 pm
- Location: Fair Green, Norfolk
- Contact:
Re: Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
Spot on Tricky, most that run this sort of layout now days have clever ways to disguise the jack plug for recharging. I have seen one using the buffers to recharge. I have even seen an N gauge layout using this. Too tiny for my shaky hands. lol. Many larger trains, you can get the very flat lipo batteries between the wheels of the loco.
Are we going the way of the electric car?.
Are we going the way of the electric car?.
Re: Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
There is also this company for battery controlled model railway engines. Seems more suitable for engines larger than OO. R-
Young at heart. Slightly older in other parts.
-
- Posts: 388
- Joined: Fri Oct 05, 2018 6:49 pm
- Contact:
Re: Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
I think that is the system I saw the components that make up the system look familiar.RogerB wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 1:45 pm There is also this company for battery controlled model railway engines. Seems more suitable for engines larger than OO. R-
Richard
-
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2018 1:48 pm
- Location: Fair Green, Norfolk
- Contact:
Re: Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
Must admit, there are a few sites out there dealing with this type of thing, but most are very poor quality sites & you wonder if to deal with them. One site that looked good was www.rctrains.co.uk But this went offline. Spoke to the fellow who owns the site & said sack your IT team. He messaged me back & said i sacked myself. oooops.
Re: Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
Got to be the way forward, anything to get rid of wireing the track
-
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2018 1:48 pm
- Location: Fair Green, Norfolk
- Contact:
Re: Anyone experienced with battery trains. ??
Its certainly a lot simpler to deal with & battery technology & RC control is getting a lot better these days.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest